Child of the Moon will be published on January 8, 2019!
Child of the Moon by Jessica Semaan
3.75 stars
“You are not a victim. You are closer to God in your pain.
For your
pain is the source of your creation. And creation
is
divine. Your pain is the source of healing yourself and
others.
And healing is divine.”
Poetry is hard to review. It’s personal, introspective, and
often times it’s more for the writer than the reader. It’s cathartic and meant
to be freeing. Child of the Moon is a process that seems to show that. The
beginning is very bitter and angry. I could feel the resentment at the trauma
Semaan faced and I was put-off. I’ll be honest, I wasn’t feeling this poetry
book because of its bitterness. Then, I kept going and I connected more, especially
in the last section—Flower Moon. I believe this is because I am more in the
same healing process of the Flower Moon than of the opening—Blood Moon. I had
once been bitter and enraged, but now when I think of that person I once was
because of the trauma I experienced I want to weep (and shout praise to God for
healing me past that brokenness). I am happy I read this because I am big
believer in talking about trauma. I believe that the trauma we experience makes
us who we truly are down to our core. Vulnerability is so important and I find
that we live in a society where everyone wants to be vulnerable, but not
actually go past the trauma. Meaning we share our trauma, but not the process
of healing. The trauma is ugly enough to compare like our latest Instagram selfies,
but God forbid, we compare the ugliest thing we as humans experience—healing.
Healing is ugly, but even more beautiful. Because you can’t get to beauty until
you’ve faced ugly. Semaan does that with her poetry collection and I respect
her for that. I needed a day to ruminate and think about this collection and I
like it more and more the further I get away from my first impression. Also, the
art in here is colorful and so great.
The problem I have with this collection is the simplicity of
the poems. My biggest complain is that the vast majority of the poems are
lists. I love lists, but I don’t think it always works in poetry format. Your
list could be the realest and truest thing out there (Healing #1 & Healing
#2), but that doesn’t make it a poem. It makes it a powerful image that will be
pinned on Pinterest. She also has a tendency to write a lot of two-lined poems.
It’s all very tumblr and quick. I’m not opposed to this form of expression, but
it isn’t really a poem, more of a reflection of a conceptual idea. The only poem
I liked that did this style was “Faith”.
Poems I Recommend:
Despair
When you can’t love yourself
When your home is a faraway land (my favorite)
Sitting with the child of the moon
What they called you
You are not a victim
Alone by the creek
“It’s never too late
to bloom.”
Whimsical Writing Scale: 3
Art Scale: 5
Plotastic Scale: 3.25
Cover Thoughts: I like the cover a lot, but I’d love it so much
more if some of the striking art that’s inside was exhibit on it.
Thank you, Netgalley and Andrews McNeel Publishing, for
providing me with a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.
Are you excited to read Child of the Moon? What poetry books do you recommend? Let me know down below in the comments!
"Poetry is hard to review. It’s personal, introspective, and often times it’s more for the writer than the reader." Wow, that's an accurate mood. I have a hard time reviewing poetry due to the personal issues and emotions that it pulls, so I almost never review them if I can avoid it.
ReplyDeleteI think simplicity of poems tend to be an issue with books from Andrews McNeel though... at least from what I've noticed by other reviewers. 😅
Haha it's so hard. I haven't started until recently, but I still find it a bit of a struggle. I definitely don't blame you from steering clear of it. Yes, Andrews McNeel is all about simple tumblr style poems and it's probably because they sale well.
Delete